Originally published on Poul Anderson Appreciation, 9 Feb 2013.
A state is, most basically, a body of armed men. In Poul Anderson's Fire Time
(London, 1977), Ishtarian civilisation has developed without a state,
yet there are bodies of armed Ishtarians, the legions, with names like
"the Zera Victrix". How does this work?
"Beronnen...had
no government...The legions...were autonomous. They hired out to
whoever would pay, on whatever terms could be mutually agreed on -
though never to anyone who attacked Beronneners." (p. 118)
The
legions sell "...protection, plus valuable civilian services; a legion
was by no means exclusively military." (p. 118) It begins to look as
though "legion" is not a fully accurate translation.
For
Beronnen and surrounding areas, it is considered a good idea to meet
occasionally in order to share information, settle disputes and plan
undertakings so societies of widely diverse kinds, some analogous to
Terrestrial social arrangements but others not, send their leaders or
representatives to an assembly that recommends but does not legislate.
Minorities usually prefer conformity to isolation.
The assembly must discuss:
"...how much territory civilization might reasonably hope to hang onto..." (p. 114)
during the next approach of the red sun.
"
'The role of the legions in this latest chaos time is likely to be more
civil than military, more engineering than fighting.' " (p. 116)
-
so the speaker proposes that the assembly should request that the Zera
return. As when writing, in the History of Technic Civilization, about
the winged and carnivorous but intelligent Ythrians, Anderson imagines
genuinely different politics for an alien species.
No comments:
Post a Comment